| Abstract|| |
Background: Carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning is a preventable disease. Patients present with nonspecific symptoms post CO exposure. Causal factors are well described in developed countries, but less in developing countries. Objectives: This study examined the characteristics of patients with CO poisoning treated at a tertiary care center in Beirut, Lebanon, and their association with the CO poisoning source. Materials and Methods: A retrospective chart review of all patients who presented to the Emergency Department (ED) of the American University of Beirut Medical Center (AUBMC) over 4-year period and for whom a carboxyhemoglobin (CO-Hb) level was available. Patients with CO poisoning diagnosis were included in the study. Patients' characteristics and their association with CO poisoning source were described. Results: Twenty-seven patients were treated for CO poisoning during the study period, 55% of whom were males. Headache was the most common presenting symptom (51.9%). Burning charcoal indoors was the most common causal factor (44.4%), whereas fire-related smoke was another causal factor. The median arterial CO-Hb level on presentation for all cases was 12.0% (interquartile range (IQR) 7.3-20.2). All patients received normobaric oxygen therapy. No complications were documented in the ED. All patients were discharged from the ED with a median ED length of stay of 255 min (IQR 210-270). Young females were more likely to present with CO poisoning from burning charcoal indoors than from another cause. Conclusion: CO poisoning in Beirut, Lebanon is mainly due to charcoal burning grills used indoors and to fire-related smoke. A clinically significant association was present between gender and CO poisoning source. An opportunity for prevention is present in terms of education and increased awareness regarding CO emission sources.
Keywords: Carbon monoxide poisoning, charcoal, developing countries, fire, Lebanon
|How to cite this article:|
El Sayed MJ, Tamim H. Carbon monoxide poisoning in Beirut, Lebanon: Patient's characteristics and exposure sources. J Emerg Trauma Shock 2014;7:280-4
|How to cite this URL:|
El Sayed MJ, Tamim H. Carbon monoxide poisoning in Beirut, Lebanon: Patient's characteristics and exposure sources. J Emerg Trauma Shock [serial online] 2014 [cited 2020 Feb 22];7:280-4. Available from: http://www.onlinejets.org/text.asp?2014/7/4/280/142762
| Introduction|| |
Carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning is common, accounting for more than 50,000 emergency department (ED) visits in the US yearly.  It is a seasonal disease with higher incidences during fall and winter months and peaks around December and January secondary to increased use of furnaces and heaters. ,
CO poisoning is also a preventable disease that can acutely lead to rapid health deterioration from seizure and death. Chronic neurologic sequelae such as memory deficits, sleep disturbances, vertigo, neuropathies, and paresthesias have also been described as a result of CO poisoning. 
The diagnosis of acute CO poisoning can be challenging since the presenting symptoms are usually nonspecific. These include but are not limited to headache, dizziness, confusion, myalgias, loss of consciousness, and death. High clinical suspicion is therefore needed to detect CO poisoning.  A serum carboxyhemoglobin (CO-Hb) level is usually ordered to confirm the diagnosis: Levels higher than 3% in nonsmokers and higher than 10% in chronic smokers are considered abnormal.  CO-Hb levels above 5% usually require treatment with normobaric high flow oxygen (administration of 100% oxygen at atmospheric pressure). This treatment speeds up the elimination of CO by shortening the CO-Hb half-life from 4 to 6 h at room air down to approximately 1 h. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy which reduces the CO-Hb elimination half-life further down to 20 min has also been recommended for serious CO poisoning including patients who have a CO-Hb level of 25% or more and patients with cardiac and severe neurologic symptoms. ,
The source of CO must be identified and removed to prevent CO poisoning. In developed countries, CO sources include house fires, faulty furnaces, inadequate ventilation of heating sources, and exposure to engine exhaust. Data from developing countries regarding this preventable disease is scarce.
Our study described demographic and clinical characteristics, causes, treatment modalities, and outcomes of confirmed cases of CO poisoning treated at a tertiary care center in Beirut, Lebanon. The study also determined the association between CO poisoning source and the different patients' characteristics.
| Materials and Methods|| |
Study setting and design
The study was conducted in the ED at the American University of Beirut Medical Center (AUBMC), a large tertiary care center in Beirut, Lebanon. AUBMC serves great Beirut area population estimated as high as 2,012,000 and has around 49,000 ED patient visits per year. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy is not available at AUBMC.
We conducted a retrospective chart review of all patients who presented to the ED from January 1 st , 2009 to January 1 st , 2013 and for whom a CO-Hb level was available. Patients who were diagnosed to have CO poisoning (International Classification of Diseases (ICD)-9 codes of 986 (Toxic effect of carbon monoxide) and E868 (Accidental poisoning by other utility gas and other carbon monoxide)) were included in the study and their corresponding electronic charts were reviewed for data collection. Data elements included date of presentation, demographic information (age and gender), presenting symptom and chief complaint, clinical characteristics (including past medical history, smoking status), CO source (charcoal or fire), vital signs at presentation, physical examination characteristics, CO-Hb levels, treatment therapy, complications in ED, and disposition.
The Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS), version 20.0 was used for data entry and analyses. Descriptive analyses were carried out by calculating the number and percent for categorical variables, whereas the continuous variables were presented as the mean and standard deviation (±SD), or median and interquartile range (IQR), as appropriate. Bivariate analysis were conducted to assess the association of the CO poisoning source and the different patients' characteristics, using Fisher's exact test for categorical variables and Mann-Whitney test for continuous ones. A P-value <0.05 was considered to indicate statistical significance.
| Results|| |
Thirty two patients had CO-Hb levels checked at AUBMC ED during the study period. Five patients were excluded since they had CO-Hb levels less than 2% and discharge diagnoses that were different from CO exposure or poisoning. Twenty-seven patients were treated for CO poisoning and were included in the study. Most of the cases presented during winter months [Figure 1]. The mean and median for age were 33.8 (±1.5) and 31 (IRQ 23.0-37.2) years, respectively with male gender accounting for 55.6% of the cases. The most common presenting symptom was headache (51.9%) followed by cough and dyspnea (33.3%), dizziness (29.6%), nausea and vomiting (25.9%), syncope (22.2%), and chest pain or palpitations (7.4%). Current smokers accounted for 37.0% of the cases. All patients had normal vital signs on presentation. Only two cases were related (two sisters) and presented simultaneously to the ED with different symptoms (one with headache and chest pain and the other with dizziness and syncope). The median arterial CO-Hb level on presentation for all cases was 12.0% (IQR 7.3-20.2). Initial CO-Hb levels ranged from 2.7 to 30%. Only two patients had an initial CO-Hb level <5% and were symptomatic after exposure to smoke from a fire. CO poisoning resulted mainly from using a grill burning charcoal indoor as an alternative heating method (44.4%). The other identified source of CO poisoning was fire (37.0%). No source was identified in five cases (18.5%).
|Figure 1: Seasonal variation of carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning cases in Beirut, Lebanon|
Click here to view
The main treatment therapy used in the ED was non-rebreather mask application (90% oxygen concentration) in 70.4% of cases. A face mask (55% oxygen concentration) was used in 22.2% of cases. The rest of the cases (7.4%) received nebulizers treatment.
No complication (seizure, syncope, loss of consciousness, or need for advanced airway management) was noted during the ED stay. Repeat CO-Hb levels were available for 18 patients with a median of 2.7% (IQR 1.7-4.8). All patients were discharged home (two patients left against medical advice prior to completing treatment). The ED median length of stay was 255 min (IQR 210-270) [Table 1].
|Table 1: Characteristics, treatment therapy, and outcomes of CO poisoning cases|
Click here to view
The comparison of two groups of patients based on CO source, that is, fire vs burning charcoal [Table 2] revealed a clinically significant association between gender and CO source (P = 0.03): Young females were more likely to present with CO poisoning secondary to using grills burning charcoal indoors, while males were more likely to present with CO poisoning from fire-related smoke. Presenting symptoms were similar for both groups with the exception of "dyspnea and cough" which was significantly more common in patients exposed to fire (P = 0.02). A nonsignificant trend towards higher initial CO-Hb levels was also found in the burning charcoal exposed group compared to the other group.
| Discussion|| |
Our study demonstrates that CO poisoning etiologies in developing countries are different from those reported in developed countries. Charcoal burning grills used indoors as a heating method in winter months account for a large proportion of the confirmed cases that were treated at the ED of a large urban tertiary care center in Beirut, Lebanon. This etiology has been previously reported in the literature as the most cause of CO poisoning in Gulf countries and among immigrants mainly Asians outside their country of origin. ,,,,, Our study however highlights further that burning charcoal is the most common cause of unintentional CO poisoning in young females in our setting. Even though the education level was not available for patients included in our study, the prevalence of this etiology in a specific group underlines the need for preventive measures in our society and possibly other developing countries in terms of public education and increasing awareness regarding sources of CO emission and the dangers of burning charcoal indoors.
Presenting symptoms of CO poisoning are nonspecific. In our study, similar to previously published literature, headache was the most common presenting symptom. , None of the patients in our study presented with seizure, flu-like, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) exacerbation symptoms which are commonly reported as presenting symptoms of CO poisoning.  This suggests that CO poisoning might be underdiagnosed or misdiagnosed as another illness in patients presenting to our ED. Previous studies have reported a misdiagnosis rate of up to 30% in CO poisoning cases. , Higher clinical suspicion and focused history on CO exposure is therefore needed to appropriately diagnose CO poisoning.
CO-Hb levels usually measure exposure levels rather than symptom severity from CO poisoning.  Stronger correlation between CO-Hb levels and specific symptoms such as loss of consciousness (levels >25%) and death (levels >50%) is present with high levels of CO-Hb.  In our study, the levels of CO-Hb fell within the range of mild exposure (<30%). No immediate complications were noted in the ED; however, long-term sequelae were not available for review. All patients had improvement in their symptoms after normobaric oxygen administration in the ED and were discharged home except for two patients who left against medical advice because of insufficient elimination of CO-Hb on repeat levels. This is consistent with previous reports regarding disposition of patients with CO poisoning treated in the ED with most patients being discharged home. 
The treatment provided in the ED consisted mainly of normobaric oxygen administration with non-rebreather and face mask; both methods provide oxygen at different concentrations. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy use has been recommended to reduce long-term cognitive sequelae in patients with CO poisoning.  In our study, hyperbaric oxygen therapy was not available; however, the administration of normobaric oxygen therapy was effective in reducing CO-Hb levels and symptoms resolution in all patients in our study.
Smoking status is an important confounding variable since chronic smokers have been reported to have CO-Hb levels as high as 10%. , Only nine cases in our study had CO-Hb levels below 10% (two <5%): Six patients were exposed to fire-related smoke. The other three patients with no identified CO source were symptomatic and nonsmokers. All of these patients were diagnosed with CO poisoning on discharge. In a study by Clarke et al., patients who presented to urban and rural EDs for a variety of symptoms were screened for CO exposure; smokers had a median CO-Hb level of 2.6% (range 0-33.3%).  In our study, symptoms were present with CO-Hb levels as low as 2.7%. This makes it difficult to exclude CO poisoning as a diagnosis solely based on CO-Hb levels even when levels are within normal ranges reported for smokers. Clinicians need to interpret the CO-Hb level carefully taking into account the whole clinical picture and presenting symptoms prior to choosing an alternative diagnosis to CO poisoning.
Our study included only patients who were diagnosed with CO poisoning and for whom a CO-Hb level was available. It is possible that other patients presenting with nonspecific symptoms from CO exposure were missed if they received an alternative diagnosis for their symptoms and a CO-Hb was not checked. Previous studies, as discussed earlier, have shown that CO poisoning is a challenging diagnosis that can be underdiagnosed or misdiagnosed in up to 30% of cases. , The incidence of CO poisoning in our setting was 0.137 per 1,000 ED visits (27 cases for 196,000 ED visits) higher than CO incidence in other settings (0.068 per 1,000 ED visits or 68 CO cases per million ED visits in Louisiana, USA). 
Another limitation is inherent to the retrospective nature of the study. Some information regarding smoking status of patients who were included in the study was missing. We only included patients who were diagnosed with CO poisoning. We would have missed some patients by adopting a specific threshold for CO-Hb levels as an inclusion criteria and attributing mildly elevated levels of CO-Hb to smoking rather than CO exposure.
Long-term follow-up was also not available for our patients, especially neurologic sequelae. The main outcomes available were those related to the acute presentation including resolution of symptoms, reduction in CO-Hb levels, complications in the ED, and patient disposition.
| Conclusion|| |
CO poisoning in Beirut, Lebanon is mainly due to charcoal burning grills used indoors and to fire-related smoke. Young females present more often to the ED with CO exposure from charcoal burning grills indoors. An opportunity for prevention is present in terms of education and increased awareness regarding CO emission sources. Patients were symptomatic with CO-Hb levels as low as 2.7%. Clinicians must have high suspicion to diagnose CO poisoning and must recognize the pitfall of excluding CO poisoning as a diagnosis solely based on CO-Hb level.
| References|| |
Hampson NB, Weaver LK. Carbon monoxide poisoning: A new incidence for an old disease. Undersea Hyperb Med 2007;34:163-8.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Unintentional poisoning deaths--United States, 1999-2004. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2007;56:93-6.
Reinisch C. Carbon monoxide poisoning: Implications for patient and family care in the emergency department. Clin Scholars Rev 2008;1:46-9.
Weaver LK, Hopkins RO, Chan KJ, Churchill S, Elliott CG, Clemmer TP, et al
. Hyperbaric oxygen for acute carbon monoxide poisoning. N Engl J Med 2002;347:1057-67.
Penney DG. Chronic carbon monoxide poisoning: A case series. In: Penney DG, editors. Carbon Monoxide Poisoning. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2008. p. 551-67.
Hampson NB, Hauff NM. Carboxyhemoglobin levels in carbon monoxide poisoning: Do they correlate with the clinical picture? Am J Emerg Med 2008;26:665-9.
Ernst A, Zibrak JD. Carbon monoxide poisoning. N Engl J Med 1998;339:1603-8.
In: Gesell LB, editor. Hyperbaric oxygen 2009: Indications and results: The Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy Committee Report. Durham, NC: Undersea and Hyperbaric Medical Society; 2008.
Al Kaabi JM, Wheatley AD, Barss P, Al Shamsi M, Lababidi A, Mushtaq A. Carbon monoxide poisoning in the United Arab Emirates. Int J Occup Environ Health 2011;17:202-9.
Wrenn K, Conners GP. Carbon monoxide poisoning during ice storms: A tale of two cities. J Emerg Med 1997;15:465-7.
Gulati RK, Kwan-Gett T, Hampson NB, Baer A, Shusterman D, Shandro JR, et al.
Carbon monoxide epidemic among immigrant populations: King County, Washington. Am J Public Health 2009;99:1687-92.
Al-Moamary MS, Al-Shammary AS, Al-Shimemeri AA, Ali MM, Al-Jahdali HH, Awada AA. Complications of carbon monoxide poisoning. Saudi Med J 2000;21:361-3.
Liu KS, Paz MK, Flessel P, Waldman J, Girman J. Unintentional carbon monoxide deaths in California from residential and other nonvehicular sources. Arch Environ Health 2000;55:375-81.
Chan KP, Yip PS, Au J, Lee DT. Charcoal-burning suicide in post-transition Hong Kong. Br J Psychiatry 2005;186:67-73.
Clarke S, Keshishian C, Murray V, Kafatos G, Ruggles R, Coultrip E, et al
. Carbon Monoxide in Emergency Departments (COED) Working Group. Screening for carbon monoxide exposure in selected patient groups attending rural and urban emergency departments in England: A prospective observational study. BMJ Open 2012;Dec 13;2. pii: e000877. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2012-000877.
Iqbal S, Clower JH, Hernandez SA, Damon SA, Yip FY. A review of disaster-related carbon monoxide poisoning: Surveillance, epidemiology, and opportunities for prevention. Am J Public Health 2012;102:1957-63.
Barret L, Danel V, Faure J. Carbon monoxide poisoning, a diagnosis frequently overlooked. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 1985;23:309-13.
Goldstein M. Carbon monoxide poisoning. J Emerg Nurs 2008;34:538-42.
Sahjian M, Frakes M. Where there is smoke. Inhalation injuries, carbon monoxide, and cyanide poisoning. Adv Emerg Nurs J 2008;30:180-7.
Bledsoe B, Nowicki K, Creel JH Jr, Carrison D, Severance HW. Use of pulse co-oximetry as a screening and monitoring tool in mass carbon monoxide poisoning. Prehosp Emerg Care 2010;14:131-3.
Hampson NB, Rudd RA, Hauff NM. Increased long-term mortality among survivors of acute carbon monoxide poisoning. Crit Care Med 2009;37:1941-7.
Katner A, Peak K, Sun MH, Badakhsh R, Woods A, Soileau S, et al
. Emergency department visits for carbon monoxide poisoning in LA. J La State Med Soc 2012;164:306-10.
Dr. Mazen J El Sayed
Department of Emergency, American University of Beirut Medical Center, Beirut
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
[Table 1], [Table 2]